Puppy Fence Incident: Tribunal Rules in Favor of Remote Worker

1

The incident occurred while Vercoe was working from her home office—a sunroom shared with her rabbit. The metal barrier, about 60cm high, was set up to separate the animals. On September 19, 2022, during a workday morning, Vercoe's foot caught on the fence while heading to her kitchen to prepare a coffee, resulting in a fall that sent her to the Royal Adelaide Hospital.

Initially, her claim was rejected by the Local Government Association Workers' Compensation Scheme, questioning whether her job significantly contributed to the injury. However, the South Australian Employment Tribunal later ruled in Vercoe's favor. According to auxiliary deputy president Jodie Carrel, the situation fell within employment-related activities, referencing the council’s endorsement of short breaks for remote employees.

Presiding over the case, Carrel emphasized that taking coffee breaks is an ordinary and expected activity for employees, remarking, "Taking a coffee break is a likely act of an employee during the course of their working day." She noted that any intent Vercoe might have had to check on the puppy did not alter the compensable nature of the coffee break.

Moreover, Carrel criticized the employer for not fully ensuring the safety of Vercoe's home workspace, aside from a checklist, stating, "effectively abrogated its responsibilities" in safety oversight. While the council was unaware of the puppy fence setup, this did not disqualify the workers' compensation claim, because the legislation does not operate on fault.

Although the case highlighted a fracture in Vercoe's arm, the extent of her knee injury, which had prior ailments, was less clear-cut and remains contested. Her legal representation dismissed accusations of exaggeration, adding that she had returned to full duties fairly swiftly and actively worked to resume her routine.

The tribunal recognized that the knee was indeed injured but was cautious concerning the duration of any temporary impairment, which was noted not to extend past September 29, 2022.

The case underlines the nuanced challenges as more people work from home, blurring the lines between home environments and workplace regulations. Such incidents stress the need for evolving safety protocols in remote work settings to adequately protect employees under similar home-working conditions.

The original coverage of the situation was reported by Insurance News Magazine, spotlighting the legal implications of remote work safety and accident liability.

Published:Thursday, 31st Oct 2024
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

National Climate Risk Assessment Unveils Growing Insurance Challenges

17 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

The Australian government has unveiled its inaugural National Climate Risk Assessment alongside a comprehensive National Adaptation Plan, highlighting the heightened impact of natural disasters on insurance accessibility across the nation. With an urgent call to action, the government acknowledges the impending climate threats and commits to intensifying efforts towards emission reduction. - read more

ASIC Extends Relief on Distribution Rules for Insurance Providers

16 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has announced an extension of the exemption allowing general insurance providers to forego appointing product distributors as authorised representatives. This decision comes with the introduction of a new legislative instrument, 2025/520, which renews the previous framework, originally established under instrument 2015/682. The relief will now continue until August 27, 2030. - read more

Cyber Insurance Becomes Essential Amid Rising Digital Threats

12 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

The recent cyberattack on Fortnum Private Wealth, accompanied by ASIC's legal action, has spotlighted the critical risks cyber threats pose to financial advice companies in Australia. With digital integration intensifying across the finance sector, the owner of Fortnum, Entireti, plans to defend the case, underscoring the necessity for ongoing vigilance in cybersecurity measures. - read more

Swiss Re Foresees Rising Premiums Amid Increasing Global Risks

10 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

In a comprehensive analysis, Swiss Re Institute predicts that global property and casualty insurance premiums will rise in tandem with GDP over the upcoming decade. This growth is driven by amplified natural catastrophe losses, asset accumulation, and heightened economic and litigation claims inflation. The institute's report outlines the evolving insurance landscape amid increasing global risks. - read more

Insurance Council of Australia Assists NSW Flood Claimants

09 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

In response to the devastating floods that swept across New South Wales' Mid North Coast in May, the Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) is taking proactive steps to support the affected residents. Insurers, organised by the ICA, will be meeting with flood victims in Kempsey, Taree, and Port Macquarie to provide guidance and support as they navigate their insurance claims. - read more

Ombudsman Upholds Policyholder’s Claim Despite Fraud Allegations

08 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

A motor insurance policyholder has won a significant dispute over fraud allegations, with the industry ombudsman ruling in favour of a payout following a controversial car accident claim. The case revolved around an incident where the claimant's wife crashed at an intersection one evening, reportedly failing to yield. The lack of photographic evidence due to shock and subsequent involvement of towing services complicated matters. - read more

Click for more Insurance News